Brought to you by the Depression Is Real Coalition, The Down &
Up Show is dedicated to the reality of depression. Our
hosts will talk with some of the world's top experts on depression, as
well as people who have been impacted by this illness. The reality
of depression is that it is a debilitating and potentially deadly
medical condition that affects more than 15 million Americans every
year. The other reality of depression is that there is hope.
Down & Up Show #12: Depression for Dummies
IAN VO DOWN & UP INTRO
The Down & Up Show on Depression Is Real.org. A talk show dedicated
entirely to the subject of depression, and the reality that there
is hope for people dealing with this disease.
DR. BAILEY INTROS DR. LAURA SMITH AND DR. CHARLES ELLIOTT
Welcome to the Down and Up Show audiocast. Today's topic is Depression
for Dummies. Our guests today are Drs. Laura Smith and Charles Elliott,
both Drs. Laura Smith and Charles Elliott are international speakers
who have clinical practices specializing in the treatment of depression
and anxiety and other mood disorders. I'm Rahn Bailey, Director
of the National Medical Association Psychiatry Section. Filling
in today for Dr. Ellen Frank.
Throughout the years Drs. Elliott and Smith have dedicated their
combined efforts with providing individuals with the resources and
knowledge to begin the healing process from within and have published
a variety of books about mental health. Today they will be discussing
with us one of their latest books, Depression for Dummies, which
is really part of this very popular dummies series. Dr. Smith and
Dr. Elliott thank you for so much for joining me today.
DR. RAHN BAILEY / DR. SMITH AND DR. ELLIOTT
DR. SMITH & DR. ELLIOTT ANSWER:
Good afternoon.
Thanks for having us.
RAHN BAILEY QUESTION:
(unint.) does a lot of so-called self help books out. But the reality
is some certainly offer more value than others. And for me books
on depression and mental health offer substantial value; my patients
see them and read them, my family and friends and neighbors and
co-workers address them. These are books that I think have moments
and actually play a role in the lives of the patients, persons and
patients I'm actually around. Tell us a little bit about what compelled
you to write this book typically as part of this ÒDummiesÓ series?
DR. SMITH & DR. ELLIOTT ANSWER:
Sure, actually the publisher asked us to write them. They first
came to us asking us to write about Overcoming Anxiety for Dummies.
And we were I think intrigued by the whole dummies series because
the whole intent of that publisher's approach is focused on accessibility.
You really strive for clarity, you use a variety of techniques like
icons and bullets and so on.
But all of that is just designed to really help clarify and focus
readers on important elements of sometimes rather complex subjects.
RAHN BAILEY QUESTION:
How long has this book been out and how É how available has it been
and how long has it been out and available?
DR. SMITH & DR. ELLIOTT ANSWER:
It was published in 2003 or about four years ago.
RAHN BAILEY QUESTION:
And has your impression been that it's been well received and that
many persons have access to it? And from what I've heard about the
series it's actually been pretty popular.
DR. SMITH & DR. ELLIOTT ANSWER
It's a very popular series. And actually the public has been very
good about buying it and liking it. We get lots of e-mails, lots
of responses from people all over the world actually that have read
the book and enjoyed it. It's also popular with professionals, psychiatrists,
psychologists, social workers, counselors, and it's been translated,
the Dummy series has been translated into many different languages
all over the world.
RAHN BAILEY QUESTION:
I think the concept really rings true that for all of us we want
to be able to capture or to grasp the essence of what a professional
or an expert is speaking about, and also in this case, in a manner
that's user friendly. It's not easy certainly practical and pragmatic
particularly with some utility or usefulness for us in our every
day lives. I've always felt that that was one reason why these books
are so helpful in psychiatry because it's the rare person if anybody
that does experience some element of psychiatry or psychological
thought concerns or issues be it in relationship or family or work
or housing or neighbors or friends in their own personal lives.
But when you use the term psychiatry or psychology or anything
that sounds formalized or organized many people tend to clam up
a little bit or maybe get a reluctant or resistant if not afraid
and they think about the big ticket issues, their concerns will
go to schizophrenia and psychosis and hospitalization and being
voluntarily committed.
So I certainly like the approach from what I understand about your
work that we would hope would make this again more user friendly
and a topic that has utility to everybody, not just that one person
in a million who has the most severe form of brain related illness.
RAHN BAILEY QUESTION:
Did you consider mental health issues that are increasingly in the
news or obviously there's É whether the gentleman at Virginia Tech,
whether he had psychiatric illness whether he was depressed or anxious
or had bipolar or the like. Were those concerns that were relevant
in addressing some hot button recent issues as well as kind of a
long term thoughts, the 40 or 50 year history of the basics of depression?
DR. SMITH & DR. ELLIOTT ANSWER
One of the things that we did throughout the book was indicate warning
signs; that if you have any kinds of thoughts of hopelessness or
helplessness or ending your life or hurting someone else that you
should immediately seek professional help. This is a very good book
to go along with other sorts of treatments as in medication or psycho
therapy.
So I think you know again throughout the book we talk about, we
don't go into specifics, but we give lots of examples of people
who really need to seek help.
DR. SMITH & DR. ELLIOTT ANSWER
And one of the things that we do talk about a lot is that depression
is an absolutely real thing and that it shouldn't be ignored. We
talk about the physical signs of depression, the aches and the pains
and the fatigue, as well as the emotional signs and the negative
thinking that happens with depression and the interpersonal problems
that often happen with depression.
It's a true mind body soul that gets affected by depression. And
you're right, I mean, it's a real É it affects the totality of both
mind and body.
RAHN BAILEY QUESTION:
And your impression and I imagine for many it's a kind of loaded
question for those of us in the mental health professions, but I
ask has it been your impression, maybe similar to mine, that with
some people they still struggle with whether or not depression is
a real or medical illness, if it's tangible, if you can do anything
about it. Or if it's like a death sentence and once you get it it's
just kind of the end of the road, and that's why so many are reluctant
to even be screened or be evaluated and why they present so much
resistance toward psychiatry.
DR. SMITH & DR. ELLIOTT ANSWER:
And I think you've hit something that many people used to think
is sort of like okay, you're depressed, just get over it, or you
have some sort of moral problem or lack of É you're lazy or something
like that. And we really are quite clear that depression is real,
it's a physical problem as well as an emotional problem and that
there are treatments that really do work.
RAHN BAILEY QUESTION:
I also imagine that some listeners today may be wondering if they
themselves have kind of a depression. I remember from the book that
there was this monitoring mood guide theoretically to encourage
listeners to you know have a mood diary so to speak to help them
understand more about their perspective, their own feelings, their
own emotions, understand their own mental health, maybe really to
kind of chronicle whether or not they were moving in an upward direction
or a downward direction toward depression themselves.
DR. SMITH & DR. ELLIOTT ANSWER
Exactly. We give people a whole list of the various types of symptoms
of depression, but one of them is simply one's mood. And by monitoring
that carefully over time people can discover patterns, the types
of events that tend to trigger their depressed moods. Sometimes
they discover when they tend to get depressed, either what time
of day or what day of the week.
They can see how their efforts progress over time and they can
determine if they not progressing that they may need to seek additional
help. So monitoring of moods is really a core piece of what people
need to do.
RAHN BAILEY QUESTION:
I would agree I think that part of our struggle in the mental health
professions is we don't do enough prevention. And I truly think,
I mean, across the board. And part of that is a struggle we have
with patients cooperating with us and part of it is that we really
need to put this you know as a higher priority and think about it
and educate others about it and make sure that it happens.
DR. SMITH & DR. ELLIOTT ANSWER
Right. And as we know depression often accompanies other physical
illness like cardiovascular problems or hormone imbalances and we
don't really no for sure whether it's first or second, the chicken
or the egg as they say.
It does seem to be some effect of depression on you know the whole
bodily system, you know, from cardiovascular to the immune system,
but then also vice versa, you know is what Laura is saying. It cuts
both ways.
RAHN BAILEY QUESTION:
Yes, clearly. I think, in fact I'm doing a piece at a cardiology
conference in October here in Houston. A good friend of mine is
a cardiologist; he's always been sensitive to these issues, and
of course the cardiology literature is increasingly you know pretty
well developed with the co-morbidity concerns of depression and
cardiovascular illness and also the outcome determinants that have
clearly shown in the last decade that you increase cardiology outcomes
if you treat people for depression whether they acknowledge upfront
symptom of depression or not.
RAHN BAILEY QUESTION:
É at least three fold the likelihood of getting, having a heart
attack if you have high blood pressure and you've not been treated
for depression. Having a heart attack if you're not treated with
anti-depressants if you have cardiovascular illness and of dying
of a heart attack if you have already had one and you have not been
put on anti-depressant therapy.
So the reality of this is there is real good data arguing that
to put somebody almost (unint.), prevention again on these meds
that's such a tremendous value. I would imagine a book like yours
gives an opportunity for us to talk about that in a sense that really
makes sense to many people.
RAHN BAILEY QUESTION:
Oh, absolutely. I'd like to hear you speak a little bit about your
latest book, Anxiety and Depression, A Workbook for Dummies.
DR. SMITH & DR. ELLIOTT ANSWER:
We actually just finished another book for dummies.
RAHN BAILEY QUESTION:
You guys are productive.
DR. SMITH & DR. ELLIOTT ANSWER
Yes, we are. (LAUGHTER) Seasonal Affective Disorder for Dummies,
which will be coming out in October. And as you know seasonal affective
disorder is another form of depression. But that's an aside. But
the Workbook is really meant to be an active adjunct É
Adjunct to therapy where a person can work with their therapist
and have lots and lots of exercises and things to do between sessions
that can really keep them very goal oriented and moving ahead.
Depression for Dummies has a lot more information about depression.
The Workbook is meant to be, as we say a workbook, which is something
that people can work through.
RAHN BAILEY QUESTION:
I think the idea of workbook implies a hands on approach that does
more than simply you show up one day and somebody tells you you
have a depression. One would love to think that what all of us do
that the more active the involvement between the health care professional
and the identified individual, identified patient the more likely
we are to have a good long term outcome.
DR. SMITH & DR. ELLIOTT ANSWER:
Absolutely.
RAHN BAILEY QUESTION:
The more likely they're more invested in what we recommend and interested
in coming for care early. All of these seem to be I would imagine
positive you know maneuvers to limit the adverse outcomes of brain
illnesses.
DR. SMITH & DR. ELLIOTT ANSWER
As you know we're psychologists, so we tend to perhaps favor cognitive
therapy. Cognitive therapy is based on the premise that the way
you think about something determines the way you feel to a large
extent. And what we like about cognitive therapy is that it has
been shown to actually improve relapse rate for depression; it's
sort of a preventative measure that you can do. And throughout the
book we have exercises and cognitive techniques as well as behavioral
techniques, as well as information about (unint.) medication.
Which also play an important role for us.
RAHN BAILEY QUESTION:
Well, clearly. As I know your psychologists, that's why I like you.
(LAUGHTER) No, I clearly think that in what we do I say we're all
part of the, this is all part of the medical profile. In the area
of medicine there's therapy and evaluation. We talk to patients,
we listen to them, we hear what they have to offer or what their
problems are, we share with them what we think may work. We try
to a trial and effect approach. I think this is the medical model.
And very often with brain illness I think because they're so complex
or complicated very often it's essential that both psychologists
and psychiatrists try to work together with multiple approaches,
probably more than one is likely to be effective at different times
in the care if you will along that line.
DR. SMITH & DR. ELLIOTT ANSWER
True, well said.
RAHN BAILEY QUESTION:
Well, I've thoroughly enjoyed meeting and talking to you. Any closing
thoughts for the listeners today and can I get É I'm Oprah Winfrey
now; I'm the host rather than the guest, so I want to get some early
tidbits of your next new book. (LAUGHTER)
DR. SMITH & DR. ELLIOTT ANSWER
Well, the next book, that's a good question. I think one closing
thought that we want to leave people with is just that depression
of any kind that lasts more than a couple of weeks is something
to really take seriously and do something about it; read about it,
learn about it, seek help, because help is available and it truly
works and it's truly treatable. The next book is Seasonal Affective
Disorder. And after that well, we're working on that. (LAUGHTER)
And I guess I would like to add that if someone in your family
shows symptoms of depression that it's a good idea to get them educated
about it. I don't want family members to begin treating other people
with depression. But the more you know about it, the better you're
able to cope with it.
RAHN BAILEY QUESTION:
That's well said. That's why information and education is probably
what we do that we have to be good stewards for information and
education that we already have and then share it as well as we can
with our patients.
DR. SMITH & DR. ELLIOTT ANSWER
Absolutely.
Well, that's just outstanding. I want to thank both of you for
joining us today and for writing this book, those books, I should
say. It clearly sounds to me, I mean, I've learned from looking
at them and I think that everyone listening today can certainly
learn about depression. It is real, it is serious, it is a brain
illness.
There are cognitive behavioral approaches that can work and I think
that people have to believe in that, to give it a chance and present
at some point to qualified mental professional hopefully early in
the process if there is a likelihood of a good overall positive
outcome. I hope that more people will find help for their depression
if they have it or if their relatives or friends or spouses, if
you will, to find help from the book you wrote I think would be
outstanding. So thank you very much for your work and for your interview
today.
For the Depression is Real Coalition, I'm Rahn Bailey. Join us
next time for another segment of The Down and Up Show from Depressionisreal.org.
Thank you very much Drs. Smith and Elliott.
IAN VO CLOSE
Thanks for listening to the Down and Up Show. For more information,
log onto www.depressionisreal.org. You can find us there and at
iTunes. And remember stay subscribed.